NYS ALLIES FOR PUBLIC EDUCATION
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Allies
  • Contact Us
  • Events/Press/Letters
    • NYSAPE Update Data Privacy
    • NYSAPE-Remembers-RegentJudithJohnson
    • NYSAPE PR OPT REMAINS STRONG
    • NYSAPE PR Elia Resigns
    • NYSAPE PR OPT OUT SCARE TACTICS
    • NYSAPE PR - Vote NO to APPR Bill
    • NYSAPE Letter to BOR - Labeling Schools
    • NYSAPE ESSA Public Comment
    • NYSAPE Repeal Ed Transformation Act-APPR PR
    • CSM-NYSAPE ESSA Opposition
    • NYSAPE SED-BOR EPIC FAIL
    • NYSAPE PR Schools NOT Penalized for Opt Outs
    • NYSAPE Local Diploma Expansion Public Comment
    • NYSAPE PR Educational and Racial Justice
    • NYSAPE PR Student Data Breach
    • NYSAPE-MPDA PR Diploma Expansion
    • NYSAPE PR ESSA - CC
    • NYSAPE PR 2017 Opt Out Results
    • ESSA Public Hearings
    • NYSAPE-PR-Remove-Elia
    • NYSAPE-PR-OptOut2017
    • NYSAPE-CSM-SED-PrivacyIssue
    • NYSED-Survey-Mtg-OTL-alert
    • NYSAPE-Memo-SED-ESSA-TestRefusals
    • NYSAPE-PR-Cuomo-DeVos-Budget
    • NYSAPE Post Election
    • NYSAPE PR CC Revisions Response
    • NYSAPE ESSA Public Comments to NYSED
    • NYSAPE Grad Req Public Comments to NYSED
    • NYSAPE ESSA Public Comments to USDOE
    • NYSAPE PR Score Analysis
    • NYSAPE PR Opt Out 16 Results
    • NYSAPE Mulgrew Response
    • NYSAPE PR Albany Refused To Fix Ed Laws
    • NYSAPE PR Fix Broken Laws
    • NYSAPE PR Elia Test Policy
    • NYSAPE Press Release School State Aid Loss
    • NYC Press Conference
    • NYSAPE PR Support New Ed Legislation
    • NYSAPE Chancellor Election
    • NYSAPE Response to HANY
    • NYSAPE PR Regent Candidates Support
    • NYSAPE Regent Candidates
    • NYSAPE Response to Tim Kremer NYSSBA
    • NYSAPE Press Release BOR Leadership
    • NYSAPE CCM Reaction Data Privacy
    • NYSAPE PR Board Regent Candidates
    • Board of Regents Candidate Info
    • NYSAPE Funding Response to USDOE
    • NYSAPE Press Release CC Taskforce
    • NYSAPE Press Release Survey Results
    • NYSAPE CC Survey Results
    • NYSAPE PR Elia Survey
    • NYSAPE PR Response to Obama
    • NYSAPE Duncan King Response
    • NYSAPE Press Release Cuomo Task Force Response
    • NYSAPE Press Release - Parents Respond to Cuomo-Tisch-Elia
    • NYSAPE Objects to Permanent Adoption of Flawed APPR Scheme
    • NYSAPE Press Release 2015 Scores
    • NYSAPE-Elia-Mtg-Recap
    • EliaMeetingHandout080415
    • NYSAPE Press Release No Relief in Sight Opt Out Will Grow
    • NYSAPE-PR-STOP CUOMO EDUCATION TAX CREDIT SCHEME
    • Albany Continues to Ignore Parents Ensuring the Opt­Out Movement Will Grow
    • NYSAPE-PR-NY-Parents-Have-Spoken
    • NYSAPE Public Service Announcement on CBS
    • New York State Parents Reject Proposed Legislation that Does Nothing to Protect Students
    • Thousands of Parents Stand Together to Reject Governor Cuomo’s
    • NYSAPE Members Addressing the NYS Legislature
    • NYSAPE Comments on ESEA Draft Legislation
    • NYSAPE FOIL Request for State Aid Budget Figures
    • New Yorkers Call for an Immediate Independent Investigation of Governor Cuomo
    • Press Release - Response to Governor's Letter on Public Education
    • NYSAPE Response Letter to Governor on Public Education
    • Parents and Educators Erupt in Anger Against Governor Cuomo's Vow to "Break" Our Public School System
    • 250,000 High-Stakes Test Boycotts Planned Statewide: NYS Parents Fight to Reclaim Student Education from Excessive Testing and Data Collection
    • Governor Cuomo’s Education Positions Aligned to Privatize Public Education
    • Parents and Educators Reject the Tests, the Scores and Corporate Agenda of NYSED & Pearson
    • Parents Outraged by APPR Albany Deal that Ignores the Children
    • State Test Refusals are exploding as Parents Discover Legislature Brings No Relief
    • NYSAPE Calls for End to Verbal Refusal Policies
    • New Yorkers Moved the Needle on the Board of Regents Vote & Process, but Not Enough
    • NYS Assembly Bill to Rein in “Regents’ Education Reform Agenda” is a Starting Point, but Not Nearly Enough
    • School Policies Regarding Test Refusals in Some NYS Districts Equate to Corporal Punishment for Students
    • NYSAPE Urges Legislators to Cast No Vote for Incumbents at Board of Regents Election if Nominated
    • Parents and Educators Outraged by Regents Unwillingness to Assume Responsibility and Change Course
    • New Yorker's Outraged by Governor's Flawed Common Core Panel
    • NYS Leadership Falls Short to Reverse Course of the Flawed Regent Education Reforms
    • NYSAPE Endorses Full Slate of Candidates for the Board of Regents
    • NYSAPE Reacts to NYSUT's Vote of No Confidence in Education Commissioner John King
    • NYS Allies for Public Education Endorses New Candidates for the Board of Regents
    • Governor Cuomo Continues to Avoid Addressing New Yorkers on Public Education
    • Community Forum Series - "Public Education Now: Reform and Resistance in NYS"
    • Senator Flanagan's Proposed Legislation Insult to the People of New York
    • New Yorkers Call on Governor Cuomo to Step Up to the Plate
    • Parents Demand More Accountability in the Appointment of Members of the Board of Regents
    • Parents Request Formal Public Meeting With NYS Board of Regents - Nov. 6, 2013
    • Twenty-Two Teachers' Unions Support Call for Education Commissioners Resignation
    • Past events
  • Take Action
    • NY Privacy Regs
    • NYSAPE-Call Albany to STOP APPR Bill
    • TAKE ACTION - NO TO APPR BILL
    • Action Alert - Give Back GATES Grant
    • NYSAPE ESSA Action Alert
    • ActionAlertNYSED-BOR-STOP-MISINFORMATION
    • Remove Commissioner Elia
    • Support OTL NY ESSA Plan
    • Education Legislation Action Alert
    • Field Test Action Alert
    • Support Ed Legislation to Repair Public Education
    • NYSAPE Legislative Agenda
    • Student Data Privacy Action Alert
    • Regents Position Paper
    • Legislators MUST Vote NO to Budget bill
    • Protect Our Schools Campaign
    • Resolution to Support the “I Refuse” Movement
    • Contact Your Legislators to Attend Regent Interviews
    • Demand Albany Stop Governor Cuomo and Chancellor Tisch's Assault on Public Education
    • Stop Mandatory Stand-alone Field Tests
    • DEMAND Education Commissioner John King and Regents Chancellor Merryl Tisch RESIGN
    • Regents Vote Scorecard
    • Scorecard For Board of Regents Vote and ACTION ALERT
    • Local PTA's Supporting Informational Meetings On Opting-Out of State Tests
    • Action Alert - Cuomo Must Step Up to the Plate
    • Support Call for Commissioner John King's Resignation
    • Action Alert - John King Must Resign
    • Resignation of NYS Education Commissioner John King
    • Return to Sender, statewide drive
    • Resolutions Against Testing
  • Student Data Privacy
  • FAQ's
    • If My Child Refuses State Tests Will My School Lose Funding?
    • If My Child Refuses State Tests Will My School Become an LAP?
  • Other Resources
    • The Early Catastrophe: The 30 Million Word Gap by Age 3
  • Press Release: Launch of NYS Allies - August 23, 2013
  • NYSAPE Objects to Permanent Adoption of Flawed APPR Scheme
  • T-shirt images
  • Oswego Letter
  • School Scare Tactics to Parents
  • 2019 ELA Teacher Feedback
  • 2019 Opt Out Factsheet
Picture
​June 28, 2016


Mr. Michael Mulgrew, President
United Federation of Teachers
52 Broadway
New York, New York 10004

Dear Mr. Mulgrew,

Over the past few years, members of the opt out movement have become adept at distinguishing our allies from those who work against us, often behind the scenes. In light of your recent newsletter (see below) for the UFT’s Unity Caucus, it has become apparent which of these two camps you are truly affiliated with.

It is no secret, Mr. Mulgrew, that as president of the NYC teacher’s union, the UFT (the largest local teacher’s union in the state), you wield a tremendous amount of power within NYSUT. With approximately 800 voting delegates and the resources needed to send all of its delegates to statewide elections, the UFT often holds the voting majority in NYSUT. Therefore, you have the power to sway NYSUT’s powerful lobbying dollars and efforts towards policy and law that will either benefit or harm our children. For that reason, the opt out movement has shifted its attention to you.

In the outrageous document referenced above, you claim that districts have "lost" grant money due to opt out, when in fact that money was not theirs to begin with. You cannot "lose" something you do not already have and are not guaranteed to be awarded. While failing to test 95% of all students may exclude a district from APPLYING for a small monetary grant (25,000-75,000 dollars), no money is TAKEN from a district. To date, no school in NYS has lost money as a result of opt out numbers. On the other hand, high stakes testing has cost school districts MILLIONS of dollars over the past four years while the State continues to shirk its obligation to fully fund our schools. In addition, under the new ESSA guidelines, this reward status and grant application process comes to an end and will no longer be a factor.

In addition to providing your members with false information, you have demonized the brave and outspoken NYC educators who have encouraged opt out. You have inexplicably labeled these educators as “reckless and feckless”. This begs the question, why would an experienced educator and union leader dismiss and insult a historic act of civil disobedience? Surely, you are aware that the opt out movement has yielded the only successful means of resisting harmful “test and punish” policies that hurt not only your members, but all educators and students around the state.

It is no secret that you have failed to support efforts to reject the increased focus on test scores in the new teacher evaluation plan (3012-d), or that you have publicly vowed to defend the common core standards (standards that even the Governor’s skewed CC task force found to be flawed) with violence, if necessary. In addition to your disparaging comments aimed at those who support the opt out movement, your actions as president of the UFT would appear to reveal whose side you are really on.

When teachers, students, and unions were being abused, demonized, and demoralized, a call to action rang out from grassroots parent and educator organizations. Many teachers and local unions heeded the call. Progressive caucuses within the UFT such as MORE and the statewide caucus Stronger Together immediately stepped up and worked alongside parents to fight for the best interests of our children. Where were you?

Sadly, it seems apparent, Mr. Mulgrew, that you have been standing and working against us at every turn. Deals have been made, hands have been shaken, and forces have aligned to quell the increasing discontent of this growing tide of parents and educators fighting for the very survival of our schools and the well-being of our children. Opposition to our cause within NYSED, NYCDOE, USDOE as well as those who support illogical and damaging education policies have found an unlikely partner in you.

While your actions speak volumes, we urge you to prove us wrong and demonstrate that you are in fact, an ally of the opt out movement. Take a stand against a corrupt and harmful test-based accountability system, advocate for research and evidence-based education policies, and respect teachers, parents, and students who advocate the use of test refusal as a means of impacting policy and regulatory change.

We think it only fair to inform you that should the educators of New York City and New York State seek new leadership in their elected union officials, the parents of New York will stand in solidarity with those who seek to safeguard public education from harmful policies, regulations, and corrupt leadership.

Sincerely,


New York State Allies for Public Education
Picture
Picture
Proudly powered by Weebly